Whats more pirate-y than that
If your collection of Magic tokens has gaps, the most common thing is probably to use a die, often on a face-down sleeved card to indicate that its a game object, not a time counter or some other marker
Temporal Forces With the powerful ACE Spec cards as their flagship product, as well as Paradox Legendaries like Iron Crown, Walking Wake, and Iron Boulder ex cards, Temporal Forces offers great value at a price of $4.49
Scraps of paper, Warhammer or D&D miniatures, pretzels and other food items, basic lands scrawled with Sharpie
In Commander, the decks that best take advantage of fogs are ones that want to win further into the late-game and dont have much to do early on outside of ramping
Stay tuned for new Commander Clash and Budget Commander featuring the new cards from Kaladesh as soon as they are available on Magic Online